some good comments here but it almost is the polar opposite of what I said in the Clayton-MegaDowntown thread... without a doubt downtown is more multi-functional and has less vacant buildings than a few decades ago, but I firmly believe the CBD needs many more jobs and we can't get too comfortable with thinking tourism/entertainment/residential growth is enough. The way I'd put it is that addressing vacancy is important, but what you fill things up with can make a vast difference in the trajectory of a city. I'd much rather have the CBD filled with a strong office worker population with a comparatively small residential population... if we had that we'd have a much higher tax base for the city as a whole along with more residents, more retail and more visitors along with less vacancy. We'd have a much stronger core that lifts the whole city.symphonicpoet wrote:This whole thread amuses me. In a good way, mind. Twenty years ago the complaint about downtown was that it was a wasteland after five, since there was virtually nothing there but offices. Now we want more offices. I think, in reality, downtown is a much healthier neighborhood than it has ever been in my lifetime. Is there room to improve? Sure. But I'm not altogether sure more offices is what it needs. I think slow, steady, organic growth that includes the continuing change of use is healthy. If businesses are in the county, fine. If they're in Cortex, great. If they're downtown, that's wonderful too. But it seems to me the biggest problem downtown, in general, is vacancy. And that's been steadily declining for twenty years, even if office vacancy has taken an upswing lately. Attracting and keeping business is certainly a worthwhile goal, but I for one don't much care what part of the region that business occupies, so long as it's here. And I don't care what's downtown, so long as it's something. Actually, a mix of uses is undoubtedly healthier than the sort of one-crop office monoculture that used to be there.
I think there is room for more everything as downtown continues to become more diverse, but the fundamental fact remains the more good-paying jobs there are downtown the more people will live there as well as surrounding neighborhoods. We need more corporate leaders to choose the Central Business District to maximize our city's (and region's) potential.






