Tapatalk

Convention Center & Dome renovation/expansion

Convention Center & Dome renovation/expansion

11K
Life MemberLife Member
11K

PostSep 26, 2007#1

(can't find any previous thread - though this comes up elsewhere)



The Cleveland Plain Dealer ran a feature on convention centers the other week comparing square feet and funding sources. IMO - St. Louis could greatly expand their convention capacity downtown and further support hotel expansion and downtown retail. They could expand into the Bottle District site or wait until the Dome may relocate and expand there. As expected, St. Louis is hamstrung for funding since it's unlikely the county would support increased taxes for expansion and the city doesn't (and won't) produce enough revenue to expand.



Cincinnati:

750,000 sq ft

Cincinnati and Hamilton County hotel bed tax, naming rights, additional city and county funding, $5M+ in state funds, $10M from local business



Columbus:

1,700,000 sq ft

~5% hotel bed tax in city and county



Detroit:

2,400,000 sq ft

Macomb, Wayne and Oakland County hotel tax and statewide hard liquor tax



Indianapolis:

1,200,000 sq ft

Marion County hotel tax, food and beverage tax, rental car tax, 1% food and beverage tax in six surrounding counties



Milwaukee:

687,000 sq ft

city and county hotel, rental car, food and beverage tax



Philadelphia:

1,300,000 sq ft

slot machine revenue



Pittsburgh:

1,450,000 sq ft

county hotel bed tax, $149M in state funds, $4M from local foundations





and finally . . .



St. Louis:

502,000 (including Dome)

city hotel and restaurant tax

1,448
Super ModeratorSuper Moderator
1,448

PostSep 26, 2007#2

Wow, I had no idea we were that far behind.

10K
AdministratorAdministrator
10K

PostSep 26, 2007#3

Grover wrote: Detroit:

2,400,000 sq ft

Macomb, Wayne and Oakland County hotel tax and statewide hard liquor tax


Wow, three counties collaborating instead of having one decide to build its own competing convention center.

3,785
Life MemberLife Member
3,785

PostSep 26, 2007#4

^It is an example of the regionalism we lack in pretty much every aspect.

125
Junior MemberJunior Member
125

PostSep 26, 2007#5

Thats very interesting..........I wonder if the lack of sq footage has eliminated us from a significant portion of convention business? From what I remember we have attracted some of the largest conventions around including the NRA and IIRC the baptist convention (both 50K+). It seems like one of the most mentioned factors for attracting conventions is number of hotel rooms, which certainly bodes well for us.

8,904
Life MemberLife Member
8,904

PostSep 26, 2007#6

^ that's because that is just our prime exhibit space...here's more info


2.7 million square feet covering 32 acres in the heart of downtown St. Louis.

Prime Exhibit Space: 502,000 square feet

Meeting Rooms: 83

Ballroom Size: 28,000 square feet

The largest in Missouri and the largest between Chicago and Dallas. Can accommodate up to 2,230 people for banquets



Ferrara Theatre Seating:



1,411 fixed seats

State-of-the-art audio-visual capabilities.


from explorestlouis.com

11K
Life MemberLife Member
11K

PostSep 26, 2007#7

^ I believe all sq ft's reflect only prime exhibit space. Or the Cleveland Plain-Dealer is lazy. Seriously, I'm more than happy to give them a call and ask for a retraction if this is their mistake.

362
Full MemberFull Member
362

PostSep 26, 2007#8

I think Saint Louis will draw its share of major conventions, like the Baptists and NRA, but it is missing out on A LOT of medium and small conventions. As a person who attends a lot of medium and small conventions, I can attest to that. I have asked executive directors in the past about doing Saint Louis and they always point to the lack of available convention oriented hotels with medium space requirements (think Peabody in Memphis, Opryland Hotel in Nashville) They also point to a general lack of activities, but namely shopping - hopefully the MX will help this. Most conventions are not interested in booking the whole convention center, but in getting 15-20 presentation rooms of varying sizes, 2-3 larger rooms for sponsor and advertising tables, small presentations around tables, and important talks, and 1 very large room (typically called a Grand Ballroom) for general sessions. Then they also need a block of 100-500 hotel rooms at that hotel or a partner hotel very close by. Directors that are looking for places with those types of accommodations are the ones skipping Saint Louis. At least that is my experience. There may be a few hotels in Saint Louis that meet those requirements, but not enough.

5,433
Super ModeratorSuper Moderator
5,433

PostSep 27, 2007#9

Doug wrote:^It is an example of the regionalism we lack in pretty much every aspect.


Maybe so, but beyond that example, I wouldn't say Detroit necessarily embraces regionalism more than St. Louis.



The convention center is a remarkable exception to the rule, but from all the accounts I've seen and heard, there's much more of a divide between city and suburbs in Greater Detroit than most metropolitan areas, even Greater St. Louis.

12K
Life MemberLife Member
12K

PostSep 27, 2007#10

I find it hard to believe that Columbus' convention center is more than three times the size of ours. Does that Morgan Quinto guy work at the Plain Dealer?

3,311
Life MemberLife Member
3,311

PostSep 27, 2007#11

Columbus:

1,700,000 sq ft

1.7 million square foot facility, including 426,000 square feet of exhibit space, two ballrooms, and 61 meeting rooms.[1]
wikipedia.



So, clearly ours is 2.7 million or 500,000 sf of EXHIBIT space.. someone needs to write a letter to the Plain Dealer.

11K
Life MemberLife Member
11K

PostSep 27, 2007#12

JCity wrote:
Columbus:

1,700,000 sq ft

1.7 million square foot facility, including 426,000 square feet of exhibit space, two ballrooms, and 61 meeting rooms.[1]
wikipedia.



So, clearly ours is 2.7 million or 500,000 sf of EXHIBIT space.. someone needs to write a letter to the Plain Dealer.


I'm on it.

6,660
AdministratorAdministrator
6,660

PostSep 27, 2007#13

I wonder if any of the others are wrong as well?

145
Junior MemberJunior Member
145

PostSep 27, 2007#14

What I found on the Greater Columbus Convention Center from their very own website and Wiki. I have family in Columbus, OH and been there many times. From what I remember its not as big as ours.



The Greater Columbus Convention Center is a convention center located in downtown Columbus, Ohio, United States, along the east side of High Street.



The convention center was designed by Peter Eisenman, constructed in 1993, and expanded in 1999. Property management company SMG oversees day-to-day operations of the 1.7 million square foot facility, including 426,000 square feet of exhibit space, two ballrooms, and 61 meeting rooms



Dimensions & Specifications

Hall Name ft Dimensions (ft x ft) Seating Capacity Booths Overhead Clearance

Battelle Hall 90,000 207 x 314 / 207 x 120 7,500 321 33'

Hall C 98,000 270 x 360 8,000 530 30'

Hall D 118,000 330 x 360 8,000 630 30'

Hall E 61,980 298 x 208 302 30'

Hall F 45,660 207 x 237.5 206 30'

Hall C & D 216,000 600 x 360 16,000 1,160 30'

Hall E & F 118,900 505 x 237.5 687 30'

2,430
Life MemberLife Member
2,430

PostSep 27, 2007#15

While St. Louis may think quantity for convention space makes all the difference, the quality of the spaces also is important. As anyone at this years APA convention in Philly can tell you, the Philly convention center maybe smaller in total size, but the quality of the facility is much higher. Nicer carpeting, decorating and interior finishes, combined with the unique location and amazing grand hall (the Philly convention center includes the former Reading Terminal Train-shed as the large ballroom space and the wonderful Reading Terminal Market below) all make it a far superior venue.



If St. Louis wants to focus on attracting more convention business (which btw is a questionable goal considering that an ever growing number of facilities compete for a shrinking pool of conventions), then the first goal should be to improve the quality of the Americas Center, which for all of its size, is a bland and characterless building inside.



One side note- the Philly adaptive reuse of Reading Terminal makes you wonder what the St. Louis convention space would be like had the region moved to make a similar use Union Station back in the mid 1980's.










6,660
AdministratorAdministrator
6,660

PostSep 27, 2007#16

^That is a beautiful building.

101
Junior MemberJunior Member
101

PostSep 28, 2007#17

^ I agree.

8,155
Life MemberLife Member
8,155

PostFeb 18, 2016#18

Consultant's report recommends doubling space:

http://www.stltoday.com/business/conven ... witterfeed

I'm very skeptical that's the right move.

20
New MemberNew Member
20

PostFeb 18, 2016#19

That building definitely needs more space and upgrades.

8,155
Life MemberLife Member
8,155

PostFeb 18, 2016#20

^ Demolishing the garage and replacing with an expanded ballroom for sure as well as carving out some more space and taking care of needed upgrades. But getting into a convention space race seems questionable..

472
Full MemberFull Member
472

PostFeb 18, 2016#21

Wow. There's the answer to an uninteresting question I had previously. :D The enclosed amusement park and monorail connected island known as Lotte World is 1,380,430 sq ft. This article states that "The convention center and Dome together are now about 500,000 square feet."

Does the expansion to 907,000 sq ft necessarily mean expansion into the bottle works area or could they build vertically?

Show of hands, who here has ever set foot in Baer Plaza? I have not. As long as the highway is there, that spot is wasted. They should build something there that doesn't block Broadway.

PostFeb 18, 2016#22

This is lame.



Better to build something like this contemporary flat iron building in Stockholm. It separates harsh industrial infrastructure from the pedestrian oriented street. A taller one on broadway would humanize the edge of the dome.

PostFeb 18, 2016#23

It says Draft but here is the report from yesterday.

http://media.bizj.us/view/img/8618732/merged.pdf

A $500 million investment and a dome dedicated only to conventions would certainly shatter all those bar graphs where Denver, Atlanta, and Nashville seem be on top.

337
Full MemberFull Member
337

PostFeb 18, 2016#24

CarexCurator wrote:It says Draft but here is the report from yesterday.

http://media.bizj.us/view/img/8618732/merged.pdf

A $500 million investment and a dome dedicated only to conventions would certainly shatter all those bar graphs where Denver, Atlanta, and Nashville seem be on top.
Let's do it.

We need all of Missouri to be on board with this, though, or at least the counties in the St. Louis Metro Area.

8,155
Life MemberLife Member
8,155

PostFeb 18, 2016#25

^ I doubt there will be much support from the state for this; and we'll be lucky if we get County on board with half.

Read more posts (673 remaining)