Joking aside, I have to agree with the others. A historic style conveys a completely different message than a modern one. Having gone to UMSL for undergrad (with its lovely early-1970s concrete "ice cube tray" ceilings), and then SLU for my Masters, my connection to the campus was completely different. SLU may not have an entirely uniform or attractive design; but walking through that campus, the feeling of belonging to something with such a tradition and legacy was striking.
Some of Wash U's newer buildings border on the gimmicky (aka "Welcome to Six Flags over Gothic University!"), but I think with age they will patina, and in 20 years or so they'll fit in as well as the old buildings.
UMSL is the ugliest and one of the most suburban campuses in the region. The campus is sterile and big box. Sometimes I feel I am going to school at Home Depot. While SLU and Wash U have suburban elements and could do more to maximize density, at least they are not as bad as UMSL. Express Scripts' new HQ is the perfect example of failure.
Standards need to be raised at SLU and WashU, but really guys, go visit UMSL and you will see how bad it is.
Well i'm sitting in the library at umsl as we speak... What the heck is so bad about it.. It may not be the prettiest campus but i wouldn't go as far to say it's ugly... I think the new MSC is pretty darn nice... How is it so big box? is it because it has 3 parking garages? It's a freaking commuter school, what do you expect. I say UMSL is just fine...It's your typical college campus. I'd say we're doing pretty well here with our two Metrolink stops...
BPE, go pick up the latest issue of The Current. Go to the letters to the editor section and read my little story about the Fee Increases.
We are building a new 4.5 million dollar parking garage on South Campus, while we are going to cut the Metro Passes. North Hanley Metrolink Station has several garages and ample parking, but few use Metro because "it does not service St. Charles." Well, our St. Charles friends can park at North Hanley for free, then use Metro one stop to North Campus.
UMSL does not promote Metrolink through marketing. Do they hand out a map of the bus routes at the beginning of the year? They should send out promotion material when you receive the invoice for your classes. Simply put, they are following the same autocentric model when they could transition students onto Metro.
Not to mention the opportunity for TOD and New Urbanism on USML's Campus or Natural Bridge. USML is an extreme disappointment as they have the opportunity to influence the minds of many St. Louis County kids, yet they propagate the suburban mentality. They are stuck in the 1970's.
I could care less about a fee increase...these things happen all the time... Umsl is dirt cheap, that's why i'm here and not at wash u or slu... They could probably use the pay increase.
bpe235 wrote:I could care less about a fee increase...these things happen all the time... Umsl is dirt cheap, that's why i'm here and not at wash u or slu... They could probably use the pay increase.
The fee increase is for student groups. As you point out, we are a suburban commuter campus. My point in the article is that student groups shouldn't be funded any further. The campus needs to be redesigned so people actually remain after classes. With all of the other fun areas in the Region, remaining at UMSL after class is at the bottom of my list. UMSL, again, needs to implement TOD and New Urbanism as this could get more student residents and keep people on campus. Not to mention, if done properly, attract employees from Express Scripts and North Park when they get off work.
bpe235 wrote:I could care less about a fee increase...these things happen all the time... Umsl is dirt cheap, that's why i'm here and not at wash u or slu... They could probably use the pay increase.
The fee increase is for student groups. As you point out, we are a suburban commuter campus. My point in the article is that student groups shouldn't be funded any further. The campus needs to be redesigned so people actually remain after classes. With all of the other fun areas in the Region, remaining at UMSL after class is at the bottom of my list. UMSL, again, needs to implement TOD and New Urbanism as this could get more student residents and keep people on campus. Not to mention, if done properly, attract employees from Express Scripts and North Park when they get off work.
Indeed indeed mr. doug. I agree completely on this one. In order to keep people around campus, UMSL would need to build dorms and/or more affordable housing around the campus. Hell I'd be even more excited if they purchased some land/housing more down the line which in turn would increase metrolink ridership. here here!
Ps. As i am a commuter I only add to the problem... But, I just purchased my semester metro pass and will riding now the it's not frigg'n freezing.
UMSL does not promote Metrolink through marketing. Do they hand out a map of the bus routes at the beginning of the year? They should send out promotion material when you receive the invoice for your classes. Simply put, they are following the same autocentric model when they could transition students onto Metro.
True enough! It's rediculous that faculty/staff and students aren't pushed/encouraged to use one of the TWO Metro stops on campus!!
UMSL does not promote Metrolink through marketing. Do they hand out a map of the bus routes at the beginning of the year? They should send out promotion material when you receive the invoice for your classes. Simply put, they are following the same autocentric model when they could transition students onto Metro.
True enough! It's rediculous that faculty/staff and students aren't pushed/encouraged to use one of the TWO Metro stops on campus!!
It really is a total travesty! They have two MetroLink stops and are thinking of cutting the student passes. It's because they do not appreciate them, or see their utility!
BTW - I think the SLU research building looks great. I can't wait for it be lit up. I actually have a good view of it straight down Chouteau from as far as Taylor.
Still too early to say, but I'm giving it mixed marks. The tower's a great addition, but like Steve says, the grassy, open area is really, really, huge. Kinda spoils the effect, IMO. Still, I really like the sculptural form of the building.
I think it will look very nice once the whole skin is on and the SLU logo up. Regarding the grassy area - this has been covered here before. For whatever reason, it was more difficult and expensive to put a building of that size further south. They put it where it is and now have room to fill in when needed. It may be 15 years, but that's the way it is.
Concrete for the fountain in the open area has been poured, and SLU's trademark fence pillars are being moved up there today from the arena site. The grassy open area should start to take shape soon. The facade looks to be nearly closed in and covered with the metal strips.
Looking at it now, I really love the building, except for the brick part at the bottom. I can live with the grassy area for a couple years, but I really want to see some plans for buildings in that area.
This is another example of an urban campus trying to be suburban. You can comment on the aesthetics all day long but it doesn't make a bit of difference if it doesn't have any spacial relationship to any adjacencies. It's not Villa Savoye you know!
the GIANT fleur de lee was out front today. While I don't like the site plan, the building looks pretty cool.
I was at Doisy today and one of the admissions counselors said that the silver cladding squares are actually solar panels... That can't be true can it? Are there any solar panels on the building?
The giant fleur-de-lys was installed atop the tower this morning. For the last few evenings, it was lit up while still resting on the ground. Perhaps it will be illuminated tonight in its new location.
IIRC, the original renderings for the building showed a full-color reproduction of the SLU crest on a backlit panel, but the final version is just an outline of the emblem housing a blue neon tube. I expect this open structure will offer less wind resistance than a solid panel. Unfortunately, the overall effect still inevitably brings to mind the grail-shaped beacon of Castle Anthrax in Monty Python and the Holy Grail....
They were testing the dancing fountain at the corner of Chouteau and Grand a couple of nights ago, but it seems to have been turned off since the weather cooled. Also, most of the area surrounding the building has now been covered with grass turf, but they still need to finish the sidewalks, etc.