491
Full MemberFull Member
491

PostApr 16, 2024#276

flipz wrote:
Apr 16, 2024
I agree it's a money grab. Hope they took out the part about equitable enforcement.
This part doesn't even make any sense. What does equitable enforcement even mean? 

Is there consideration of who the victims are of these accidents?  Wouldn't it be most equitable & inclusive to reduce the traffic violence a community experiences?

13K
Life MemberLife Member
13K

PostApr 16, 2024#277

RockChalkSTL wrote:
Apr 16, 2024
In addition to the red light cameras, I'd love to see what the city did on Louisiana Ave. and copy/paste it all around the city. 
"The revenue from the fines won’t go to the city’s general-use fund as it once did, either. Instead, it will be earmarked to first cover the cost of administering the program for city police and courts and then pay for improvements to neighborhood streets and sidewalks."

1,878
Never Logs OffNever Logs Off
1,878

PostApr 16, 2024#278

_nomad_ wrote:
Apr 16, 2024
The only reason yellows "aren't long enough" is if the driver is already speeding too fast. Drive a reasonable speed and you won't be caught out by the light.
In the past some municipalities have intentionally shortened the duration of the yellow lights in order to generate more red light tickets, and thus more ticket revenue:

https://ww2.motorists.org/blog/6-cities ... or-profit/
3) Springfield, Missouri
The city of Springfield, Missouri prepared for the installation of a red light camera system in 2007 by slashing the yellow warning time by one second at 105 state-owned intersection signals across the city.

The city defended its effort to the Springfield News-Leader by claiming it was “standardizing” and had increased the yellow time at 136 city-operated lights to meet national standards. During the city council meeting last October where the red light camera ordinance was approved, however, Assistant Director of Public Works Earl Newman gave a different explanation for the reduction. Newman said he was, “concerned that many individuals run the light if the light remained yellow too long.”
-RBB

6,157
Life MemberLife Member
6,157

PostApr 17, 2024#279

hebeters wrote:
Apr 16, 2024
The last major traffic study from dept trans of Ohio  indicates that red light cameras DON'T decrease accidents / public safety. They DO decrease t-bone accidents but increase rear end collisions. The best solution, that dropped ALL accident rates - increase the length of the yellow light. This is a momey grab under the guide of public safety. Street calming measures (narrower roads, etc) increase public safety, actual accountability - police in force yanking unregistered cars and three year old temp plates, Increase safety - this ain't it (IMO).
It's worth noting that t-bone accidents are among the most serious and dangerous, and rear end accidents are noticeably less so, thanks in part to the layout of automobiles, but also, interestingly, to the layout of our own anatomy. The head trauma from side impacts is considerably worse. I don't think red light cameras are a perfect solution, or that they can't be abused, but if used sensibly I truly believe they have a role to play. Likewise speed cameras.

1,213
Expert MemberExpert Member
1,213

PostApr 25, 2024#280

^ Agreed. Instead of number of accidents, I'd be more interested in number of serious injuries. I'd trade 1 serious accident for 3 less serious ones.

2,663
Life MemberLife Member
2,663

PostApr 25, 2024#281

Start enforcing license plate registration or this will be for nought. I would bet the Venn-diagram of people running red lights and those with expired/temp/no tags looks pretty circular.

If your tags are more than a year out of date the car should be immediately impounded. Don't make it a criminal offense, don't even ticket the people (they won't pay) just take away the car. Implement this policy with a one year grace period so people who are having a hard time affording registration can get their affairs in order. IE save up to properly register your car, or sell the thing and either buy a cheaper car or move somewhere you can live car free.

I'm just so sick of living in a city where a subset of people just don't have rules apply to them. These 5% of lawless drivers are responsible for a far outsized percentage of road and pedestrian fatalities, and since they don't have license plates it's more likely they just drive off and never get caught. A friend of mine was just hit on her bike by one of these bozos running a stop sign. She was pretty injured and the driver just sped away. It's really unfortunate that hit and runs are becoming the norm in this city.

9,674
Life MemberLife Member
9,674

PostApr 25, 2024#282

kipfilet wrote:
Apr 25, 2024
^ Agreed. Instead of number of accidents, I'd be more interested in number of serious injuries. I'd trade 1 serious accident for 3 less serious ones.
You’re in luck!
https://x.com/beganovic2024/status/1780 ... 00755?s=46

1,213
Expert MemberExpert Member
1,213

PostApr 25, 2024#283

dbInSouthCity wrote:
Apr 25, 2024
kipfilet wrote:
Apr 25, 2024
^ Agreed. Instead of number of accidents, I'd be more interested in number of serious injuries. I'd trade 1 serious accident for 3 less serious ones.
You’re in luck!
https://x.com/beganovic2024/status/1780 ... 00755?s=46
That's great, thanks for sharing!

9,674
Life MemberLife Member
9,674

PostApr 25, 2024#284

kipfilet wrote:
Apr 25, 2024
dbInSouthCity wrote:
Apr 25, 2024
kipfilet wrote:
Apr 25, 2024
^ Agreed. Instead of number of accidents, I'd be more interested in number of serious injuries. I'd trade 1 serious accident for 3 less serious ones.
You’re in luck!
https://x.com/beganovic2024/status/1780 ... 00755?s=46
That's great, thanks for sharing!
That data, like the post it’s quoted is for crashes where a signal violation was the main cause of the crash. (That will always be the main cause even if there is speeding)

13K
Life MemberLife Member
13K

PostJun 10, 2024#285

Stop sign cameras. The whiney entitled driver doesn't make much of an argument.

https://www.nbcnews.com/nightly-news/vi ... 2594245602

3,762
Life MemberLife Member
3,762

PostJun 10, 2024#286

^ love it. put 'em everywhere. i'm f*cking over drivers.

296
Full MemberFull Member
296

PostJul 09, 2024#287


3,762
Life MemberLife Member
3,762

PostJul 09, 2024#288

^ i hope so, though it's hard to compete with drivers when it comes to killing. i never get tired of them crying about how they shouldn't be held accountable for constantly breaking laws that exist to prevent them from murdering people.

667
Senior MemberSenior Member
667

PostJul 09, 2024#289

How will this affect those driving around with expired temp tags or cars with no license plates? I see so many cars in North St. Louis that don't have license plates driving around recklessly. The other day I saw a Toyota Avalon on Goodfellow running though a red light with expired tags from 2020! I am not a fan of redlight cameras because they aren't about safety and more about revenue generating. Also, the camera operators get quite a commission from each violation too.

13K
Life MemberLife Member
13K

PostJul 09, 2024#290

And the companies who make all the stuff police use make money too
The revenue will help pay for street improvement to protect us from drivers. Though it will surely dwindle since drivers will start behaving with enforcement, right? People cry for enforcement .... of others

788
Super MemberSuper Member
788

PostJul 09, 2024#291

10-intuition wrote:
Jul 09, 2024
How will this affect those driving around with expired temp tags or cars with no license plates? I see so many cars in North St. Louis that don't have license plates driving around recklessly. The other day I saw a Toyota Avalon on Goodfellow running though a red light with expired tags from 2020! I am not a fan of redlight cameras because they aren't about safety and more about revenue generating. Also, the camera operators get quite a commission from each violation too.
I don't know if they're sticking with the 'equitable enforcement' part but that was supposed to be part of it and should tell you your answer. They don't care to uphold the laws, this is a money grab.

13K
Life MemberLife Member
13K

PostJul 09, 2024#292

Just don't break the law, and you won't have to worry about it.

2,663
Life MemberLife Member
2,663

PostJul 09, 2024#293

STL needs to start pulling these cars with greatly expired temp tags (or no license plate at all) over and impounding the vehicles. Maybe give a 90 day grace period to the expired temp tags where you just get a ticket but keep the car.

Give residents a year to get their affairs in order. IE either pay your sales tax and insurance to get legal plates, or sell your car if you don't have the funds to sustain the PRIVILEGE of driving. 

If your car is at the impound lot, you can get it back when you bring valid plates. Maybe contract with some mechanics that can inspect these vehicles at impound and fix violations to help with this process

13K
Life MemberLife Member
13K

PostJul 09, 2024#294

IDK, sounds like a money grab to me.

2,663
Life MemberLife Member
2,663

PostJul 09, 2024#295

Something needs to be done about these unregistered cars though, 75%+ of the dangerous car hijinks I've encountered involves these cars emboldened by their anonymity. My wife was recently in a minor hit and run fender bender which was infuriating, but it gets so much worse than that. Several members of the biking community have been hit and run just in the past six months, at least a couple of them being seriously injured by the encounter.

13K
Life MemberLife Member
13K

PostJul 09, 2024#296

Cars need authentication schemes to verify license, registration, and insurance. But we don't like actual enforcement, just cat and mouse. 
The state passed the mind boggling amount of money to stand up sales tax collection at point of sale for cars.

981
Super MemberSuper Member
981

PostJul 09, 2024#297

quincunx wrote:Cars need authentication schemes to verify license, registration, and insurance. But we don't like actual enforcement, just cat and mouse. 
The state passed the mind boggling amount of money to stand up sales tax collection at point of sale for cars.
Why do you say “we don’t like actual enforcement”? From what I can see, stricter enforcement auto authentication is overwhelmingly popular.

13K
Life MemberLife Member
13K

PostJul 09, 2024#298

No, drivers want to be able to break the law at their discretion. Enforcement is for others.

981
Super MemberSuper Member
981

PostJul 09, 2024#299

quincunx wrote:No, drivers want to be able to break the law at their discretion. Enforcement is for others.
I think you’re misrepresenting the opinion of most drivers. Stricter enforcement of things like license plate tags, and traffic laws in general seems overwhelmingly popular.

13K
Life MemberLife Member
13K

PostJul 09, 2024#300

I'm talking about speed governors and cars authenticating license, registration, and insurance before they will move (maybe they could go max 10 mph without it). Actual enforcement, not cat and mouse, not "no cop, no stop, " no "I was only 5 over," no "I can drive 100 mph if I decide my emergency justifies it." Traffic laws are popular for the other drivers - see the whining over the red light cameras. When they think they'll get caught when they break the law, then it's an overreach.

Read more posts (31 remaining)