FFGump wrote:Bad stewardship for the thousandth time.
I agree. And that's why I seek forgiveness for my cynicism.
The reason I suggested the city might be okay with a bank or a fast food restaurant is because there is a pattern in place where low expectations are the norm, resulting in compromised projects that do little if anything to add to the unique charm and character of city neighborhoods.
The scale of these projects is much larger than Fleur de Lis, but I'm reminded of Southtown Centre and Loughborough Commons, both of which could have been planned much better. Instead, we got typical strip malls in both locations with no respect for the surrounding built environment.
The result at Southtown is particularly bad, because like those houses on Texas Avenue, the old Famous-Barr was senselessly demolished for a home improvement store (and later a K-Mart) that never materalized. The Southtown Coalition proposed a sensible, attractive, and dense development that made the most of that site, not unlike what Fleur de Lis would've done for the corner of Arsenal and Jefferson. And in the end, the people of the community wound up with a strip mall that was no better than the home improvement store and Kmart that were previously proposed.
Like you, I think Ald. Ortmann will seek a higher standard here, and I think a developer could make the Fleur de Lis concept (or something similar in size and scope) work at this site. Economic conditions right now make the idea somewhat less favorable, but if the city assumes control and shops the site around to qualified developers, you never know. Despite a rather bleak national economic outlook, a lot of projects are still going forward, which is an encouraging sign in our "neither boom nor bust" community. Since no one knows for sure, we'll have to take a wait and see attitude, but at least it seems like people in the community are committed to ensuring that a future proposal for this land embraces the best and highest use concept.