9,545
Life MemberLife Member
9,545

PostApr 24, 2024#5426

Debaliviere91 wrote:
Apr 24, 2024
dbInSouthCity wrote:
mullanphy wrote:
Apr 24, 2024
I think you might just be hesitant about accepting a little positive news about Downtown. A 16% increase in visitors downtown from March 2023 (A warmer month with a NCAA MVC basketball tournament, the opening of CityPark, and a large St Patricks Day event) to February 2024 (A colder month without notable large events downtown) seems like good news any way you package it.
The 16% increase only counts a very small part of the downtown CBD and doesn’t include downtown west.  The study was always dumb. We have spending data that shows downtown west way above 2019 and downtown as a whole is at about 99% of 2019.
When you say DT spending is at 99% of 2019 as a whole, does this account for inflation? The average cumulative rate of inflation from 2019 to 2024 is over 22%. So if it’s not adjusted, that would indicate actual instances of spending are still at a little over 75% of where we were at in 2019. That would be your loose correlation to spending indicating changes in traffic.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Waiting for the state to post Q4 2023 data to compete the year.  STL inflation 2019-2023 was about 19.1.   Biggest drivers on inflation were used cars and housing.  We have no car dealers in downtown nor is housing taxed.
I’ll include the real number too (inflation adjusted) when it comes out

474
Full MemberFull Member
474

PostApr 24, 2024#5427

^ in that case, unfortunately, spending data might not be a true representation of how downtown is doing since we have no apples to apples comparison as there are lot of new restaurants which didn't exist before pandemic. 

Sorry if you have to repeat yourself but what are the major drivers of spending data? I hope it is not hotels.

9,545
Life MemberLife Member
9,545

PostApr 24, 2024#5428

stlurbanist wrote:
Apr 24, 2024
^ in that case, unfortunately, spending data might not be a true representation of how downtown is doing since we have no apples to apples comparison as there are lot of new restaurants which didn't exist before pandemic. 

Sorry if you have to repeat yourself but what are the major drivers of spending data? I hope it is not hotels.
^ I’m sorry don’t mean to be rude but you should go back and read what you said.   The fact that we have new and more restaurants is a good thing, it shows growth and that’s exactly how downtown grows, new things to see and experience.  Union Station in its current form opened in like Oct 2019, in 2019 there was $27,000,000 in sales on that site and in 2023 I think it will come at about $80,000,000, that’s real growth by having million+ more visitors in 2023 over 2019

And no, it’s not hotel, they’re down about 18% since pre covid

474
Full MemberFull Member
474

PostApr 24, 2024#5429

^ all good. you didn't sound rude. i am still a learner and a junior member. i was being a devil's advocate....

PostApr 24, 2024#5430

but shouldn't we also factor in the lost revenue from closed restaurants if we want to make the spending numbers foolproof?

2,419
Life MemberLife Member
2,419

PostApr 24, 2024#5431

More restaurants have opened than closed downtown. That's what he's going to tell you. 

There is real reason for optimism with downtown St. Louis. Let yourself feel it!

977
Super MemberSuper Member
977

PostApr 24, 2024#5432

dbInSouthCity wrote:
Debaliviere91 wrote:
Apr 24, 2024
dbInSouthCity wrote: The 16% increase only counts a very small part of the downtown CBD and doesn’t include downtown west.  The study was always dumb. We have spending data that shows downtown west way above 2019 and downtown as a whole is at about 99% of 2019.
When you say DT spending is at 99% of 2019 as a whole, does this account for inflation? The average cumulative rate of inflation from 2019 to 2024 is over 22%. So if it’s not adjusted, that would indicate actual instances of spending are still at a little over 75% of where we were at in 2019. That would be your loose correlation to spending indicating changes in traffic.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Waiting for the state to post Q4 2023 data to compete the year.  STL inflation 2019-2023 was about 19.1.   Biggest drivers on inflation were used cars and housing.  We have no car dealers in downtown nor is housing taxed.
I’ll include the real number too (inflation adjusted) when it comes out
That’s fair. But inflation is still going to be a big factor even when you pull out housing / cars. I’m just trying to show spend data is a far from perfect metric to indicate changes in traffic patterns.

The fact that spend has stayed at 99% overall when comparing 2019 to now is for sure an indicator of the economic resilience of DT.

9,545
Life MemberLife Member
9,545

PostApr 24, 2024#5433

RockChalkSTL wrote:
Apr 24, 2024
More restaurants have opened than closed downtown. That's what he's going to tell you. 

There is real reason for optimism with downtown St. Louis. Let yourself feel it!
Number opened or closed isn’t really relevant- what’s relevant is net dollars spent, for example through first 9 months of 2023 for full service sit down restaurants there was $334m in sales in STL City or +25% from same period in 2019.  In chesterfield it was +10% and Clayton +4%.   If you want to use that 19% inflation to walk back those, City comes at +6% from 2019, Chesterfield at -9% and Clayton at -15%.

1,607
Totally AddictedTotally Addicted
1,607

PostApr 24, 2024#5434

stlurbanist wrote:
Apr 24, 2024
but shouldn't we also factor in the lost revenue from closed restaurants if we want to make the spending numbers foolproof?
You don't subtract the "lost revenue" dollar amount because there simply isn't any revenue from a shuttered restaurant or business.  It's a zero number, not a negative number. 

121
Junior MemberJunior Member
121

PostApr 25, 2024#5435


7,803
Life MemberLife Member
7,803

PostMay 13, 2024#5436



Interesting culture "clash" Saturday night as all three of these events in Downtown West let out around 9:00 to 10pm Saturday night
-UFC at Enterprise
-St. Louis Symphony at Stifel
-City SC soccer match at CITYPARK

114
Junior MemberJunior Member
114

PostMay 17, 2024#5437

https://www.bizjournals.com/stlouis/news/2024/05/17/railway-exchange-millennium-hotel-city-plan.html

Been out of the loop (hadn't been fallowing stl urbanism and related things since 2017. ) But  what can we expect from this? I think primary residential is the way to go.

320
Full MemberFull Member
320

PostMay 17, 2024#5438

Missouri lawmakers pass historic tax credit overhaul seen as key to AT&T, Railway Exchange rehabs
Missouri lawmakers on Thursday passed legislation that a preservation official and developer described as key to aiding redevelopment of two of downtown St. Louis' giant vacant buildings, while other priorities for the area failed to advance.
Changes to the state's historic tax credit program passed the House on Thursday after clearing the Senate on May 7, inside a bill that prevents local governments from enforcing a moratorium on evictions unless allowed by state law, a response to rules crafted amid the Covid-19 pandemic.

But the bill, via amendments, also includes changes to the tax credit program. "The legislature understands the significance of the fiscal impact of historic tax credit projects across the state and understands the complexities of historic project conversions and rehabilitations, and this legislation will help toward filling the gap that exists with these projects," said Charles Goldman, whose firm bought the vacant, 44-story AT&T tower in April for $3.6 million.
The legislation makes several changes to the historic tax credit program, according to Jim Farrell, president of Historic Revitalization for Missouri, an industry association addressing the legislative and regulatory aspects of historic rehab projects.
In one change, he said, projects over 1 million square feet — which affects the AT&T tower and the Railway Exchange Building — can collect state historic tax credits over six years rather than one. The effect is that if the projects seek credits in the same year, for example, they won't take up all of the $104 million available to those in non-qualified census tracts. Under the current rules, a $60 million award to both projects, for example, would "really then shut out other projects around the state," Farrell said.
The legislation also sets a deadline for the State Historic Preservation Office to review projects within 60 days. If they don't, Farrell said, the office won't be able to require more work on applications.
"Projects the last several years have been taking anywhere from six months to a year for review," Farrell said. "That resulted in projects costing hundreds of thousands of dollars more through interest rates and gap financing."

And the legislation increases from 25% to 35% the tax credit available to projects for counties outside St. Louis and Kansas City, Farrell said.
He said Sen. Steve Roberts, D-St. Louis, and Rep. Travis Wilson, R-St. Charles, worked on the provisions.
https://www.bizjournals.com/stlouis/news/2024/05/17/missouri-lawmakers-tax-credit-overhaul-att-railway.html

PostMay 21, 2024#5439

Credit union puts downtown headquarters up for sale, plans exit from neighborhood
One of the region's largest credit unions is marketing its downtown St. Louis headquarters for sale, with the eventual goal of exiting the neighborhood altogether.
Gateway Metro Federal Credit Union placed its building at 1001 Pine St. up for sale in the past several weeks with an asking price of $1.25 million, said CEO Jay Lewis. The two-story building, solely occupied by the credit union, houses its administrative offices and Gateway's branch in the city of St. Louis, one of six locations it operates throughout the region.

The 16,247-square-foot building on a 0.18-acre lot, which Lewis said was constructed on top of the foundations of row houses that had originally been built in the 1800s, was appraised at $1.09 million this year by the city assessor, records show. City records do not list when it was built, but it operated as a Catholic bookstore before the credit union bought it and moved there from another downtown building in the early 1990s, Lewis said. The decision to list the building is part of a plan by the 53-employee credit union to exit downtown for a location elsewhere in the city or eastern St. Louis County and expand its appeal, particularly to younger people, Lewis said.
“We’re just looking to get out of downtown,” Lewis said. “The vibe downtown isn’t like it used to be.”
The credit union will be the latest company to announce a move out of downtown, even as government officials and boosters look for answers on big vacancies. New developments such as the proposed $1.2 billion Gateway South construction innovation district and new attractions at Union Station are planned, but the downtown market has struggled to recover office tenants and foot traffic after the Covid-19 pandemic.
https://www.bizjournals.com/stlouis/news/2024/05/21/credit-union-building-sale-downtown-exit-gateway.html?cx_testId=40&cx_testVariant=cx_5&cx_artPos=0#cxrecs_s

8,905
Life MemberLife Member
8,905

PostMay 21, 2024#5440

Nice! That’s a perfect lot for a tear down.

9,545
Life MemberLife Member
9,545

PostMay 22, 2024#5441

Very good timing. ATT owner is in talks to buy lot behind ATT and this now makes sense for a ATT parking structure that’s connected with ped walkway. Weather we like it or not, if you’re going to put 400-500 units in ATT it will have to come with 1 to 1 parking ratio

2,678
Life MemberLife Member
2,678

PostMay 22, 2024#5442

I know it's not what most of us want, but is this enough space to find a parking solution for AT&T?
Screenshot 2024-05-21 201203.png (3.06MiB)

474
Full MemberFull Member
474

PostMay 22, 2024#5443

We have too much dependence on parking - what a pity.

9,545
Life MemberLife Member
9,545

PostMay 22, 2024#5444

addxb2 wrote:
May 22, 2024
I know it's not what most of us want, but is this enough space to find a parking solution for AT&T?Screenshot 2024-05-21 201203.png
This is what I suggested to Goldman last month. Kinda wild this lot became available. Other option was digging but that’s just too much $

193
Junior MemberJunior Member
193

PostMay 22, 2024#5445

Pretty scathing remarks so not surprised it's the front page of the Business Journal.  But seriously, this is such a weird article.  If I'm trying to sell a building I own, why would I trash the building, the area, the foot traffic, the safety, and the "vibe"?  How is that going to get me the best price?!  

This seems like a great location for apartments, but understand that parking is needed for AT&T to get done.  Hopefully there is at least retail incorporated into the parking garage.  In fact, I think that should be a requirement for any new parking garage built.  

2,623
Life MemberLife Member
2,623

PostMay 22, 2024#5446

If Le Meridian want's to play ball they could probably extend west into their little valet/dropoff area. They could incorporate the dropoff loop into the new garage and probably get some parking spots out of it.

9,545
Life MemberLife Member
9,545

PostMay 22, 2024#5447

If you’re an early Saturday riser, tune into KMOX at 7:00am to hear my chat with Rachel Zimmerman (co host of Dave Glover show and has her own weekly 30 min show that airs
Or Saturdays)
Or if you’re too hungover, catch it here later
https://www.audacy.com/podcasts/the-rac ... how-515206

We talk about crime, downtown, pocket parks and a few other City things

2,074
Life MemberLife Member
2,074

PostMay 22, 2024#5448

addxb2 wrote:
May 22, 2024
I know it's not what most of us want, but is this enough space to find a parking solution for AT&T?Screenshot 2024-05-21 201203.png
The giant parking structure on the left is like 95% empty every day. Surely most if not all of the building's parking can be satisfied with it.

406
Full MemberFull Member
406

PostMay 22, 2024#5449

bprop wrote:
May 22, 2024
addxb2 wrote:
May 22, 2024
I know it's not what most of us want, but is this enough space to find a parking solution for AT&T?Screenshot 2024-05-21 201203.png
The giant parking structure on the left is like 95% empty every day. Surely most if not all of the building's parking can be satisfied with it.
Yeah, but then people might have to actually walk...which *gasp*..when presented as the choice downtown...many a folks legs suddenly are broken and incapacitated. Walking? In this economy on those blocks?! Don't you know we have cars?! Ain't nobody got time for human interaction in the age of AI!! 

💩

79
New MemberNew Member
79

PostMay 23, 2024#5450

Chestnut (from 4th to 20th) would be my pick for full pedestrianization(and a better alternative alignment for Brickline).  Utilizing the parking at 11th and chestnut (off Pine) for  ATT would then be an easier ask (though this intersection and 10th are already pretty low stress).  Though I'm not against new parking structures on those lots.  Anything is better than a flat lot.  

Read more posts (2443 remaining)