goat314 wrote:I think it's kind of a chicken-egg thing. On one hand, the lack of economic development and educational opportunities in the city of St. Louis causes many of these problems, but these problems are also a major deterrent to most people (regardless of race, socioeconomic standing etc.) from living or doing business in the city. I think we need real reform in St. Louis on so many levels or these problems will continue to harm the quality of life and perception of the city as a whole, which has real life consequences.
Obviously, stop and frisk is a very sticky subject. For one, it will almost certainly be used to harass any black male of a certain age, whether they are a "criminal" or not. This alone makes it dangerous. The fact is we "DO" have some racist police officers and they "WOULD" use it as an excuse to harass any and every black male they come across, which is why it was met with so much backlash in NYC. On the other hand, we simply cant let the criminal element run rampant and wild throughout the city of St. Louis and region. White people are up in arms when an "innocent" white person gets beat up by a black "mob", just like black folks are up in arms when an "unarmed" black man gets gunned down by a white "cop". The fact remains, the majority of people murdered, robbed, and assaulted in the city of St. Louis live in impoverished, Afro-American neighborhoods and were likely involved in illegal activity. What is truly sad is that there are open air drug markets, rolling gun battles, armed robberies, etc. throughout the city of St. Louis everyday and somehow the police can never catch the perpetrators. The people who suffer the most are the children who get hit by stray bullets, the family that is forced to leave North St. Louis because they are constantly getting their house broken into, the elderly person who is scared to walk to church because gangbangers are hanging on the corners, and the people who are trapped in food deserts because no grocery store will open in a neighborhood with open air drug markets. How do we continue to let this happen in St. Louis? Many cities are starting to clean up their act, some even "blacker" and "poorer" than St. Louis. It truly is a shame. Everybody talks about Chicago, but if we had their murder rate we would have about 50 murders/year, if they had ours they would have about 1500 murders/year.
It is sort of a chicken and egg thing, but I think the primary instigator of this viscous cycle still has to be identified as the behavior of a small but menacing subset of the population.
You can't blame it all on racism and white flight, because anybody that has the means, no matter what color, has chosen to flee these neighborhoods. The Black middle class also moves out. They're not racist. They just want a safe place to live.
I tend to think that "all of the above" are true when talking about our country's and our region's urban social problems. It is partly because the perpetrators are just terrible people, partly poor parenting, partly the lack of resources and/or lack of anything better to do, partly the dilapidated state of the infrastructure which adds to the collective lack of esteem for the area...
And yet all we get is a finger-pointing war, with no actual action to improve things. Conservatives only want to focus on personal responsibility, liberals only want to focus on external and systemic shortcomings. Each individual circumstance has a different mix of the above factors at play, and collectively, you're not going to solve the problems unless you focus on each one of them. As a liberal, I find it irritating when other liberals apologize for criminal behavior, make excuses, and focus only on the rights of the perpetrator. A lot of these people make a lifetime and a living out of violating the rights of others.
But then conservatives have to admit that our economic system is fundamentally flawed if it creates no jobs, resources, purpose, or role in society for a lot of people in this country. If the only reason you're supposed to invest is for the profit motive, you shouldn't be surprised that poor neighborhoods are made worse by being choked from investment. There's no immediately attainable profit in trying to solve social problems, so the market is not going to come up with a solution to any of this--it's just going to ignore it and make it worse.