415
Full MemberFull Member

Post6:46 PM - Oct 18#26

I have been up in it as well.  I hope they are able to raise the funds.  I would like to see it open again.  I thought I paid to go up?  So that could be a source of revenue for maintenance (once restored).  

497
Full MemberFull Member

Post1:40 PM - Oct 19#27

STLCityMike wrote: ↑
6:46 PM - Oct 18
I have been up in it as well.  I hope they are able to raise the funds.  I would like to see it open again.  I thought I paid to go up?  So that could be a source of revenue for maintenance (once restored).  
It was closed due to the maintenance issues. They are not cleared for the public to enter due to the conditions. So unfortunately that is no longer a viable revenue source. Though, I doubt those admissions would have ever tallied up enough to cover ongoing maintenance. It's going to take donor/sponsor interventions. Of the $8 million needed, $500k alone is needed for the consult/inspection/permits for construction. It's a bear....I'm very hopeful the community rallies, because losing this landmark would be frankly, perverse. It's too important.

1,717
Totally AddictedTotally Addicted

Post2:47 PM - Oct 19#28

How is this landmark and its decades long plight not been handled by the alderperson nor given ARPA funds?

It is a historic landmark in a city park, yes?

497
Full MemberFull Member

Post3:03 PM - Oct 19#29

TheWayoftheArch_V2.0 wrote: ↑
2:47 PM - Oct 19
How is this landmark and its decades long plight not been handled by the alderperson nor given ARPA funds?

It is a historic landmark in a city park, yes?
It's on the national register and also a city declared landmark. Also, the city still owns it...so, theoretically they can summon funds, if they so choose. 

344
Full MemberFull Member

Post3:04 PM - Oct 19#30

SRQ2STL wrote: ↑
3:03 PM - Oct 19
TheWayoftheArch_V2.0 wrote: ↑
2:47 PM - Oct 19
How is this landmark and its decades long plight not been handled by the alderperson nor given ARPA funds?

It is a historic landmark in a city park, yes?
It's on the national register and also a city declared landmark. Also, the city still owns it...so, theoretically they can summon funds, if they so choose. 
Yeah does this not seem like a Rams money-type of emergency?

1,893
Never Logs OffNever Logs Off

Post7:21 PM - Oct 19#31

Or a 'the city has a $40m+ budget surplus this year' type of emergency... 

-RBB

502
Senior MemberSenior Member

Post7:38 PM - Oct 19#32

Id like to register the opinion that I love old structures like this - I also dont see a world where I could support spending $8M of the city's money to save this.  

Some people can raise some money if they love it - I would maybe donate, but asking the city or water department to save it seems like a low priority to me. Doing it the way the are seems great, giving several years of runway, letting people know they need to contribute if they want to save it, etc. 

1,165
Expert MemberExpert Member

Post8:08 PM - Oct 19#33

mjbais1489 wrote:Id like to register the opinion that I love old structures like this - I also dont see a world where I could support spending $8M of the city's money to save this.  

Some people can raise some money if they love it - I would maybe donate, but asking the city or water department to save it seems like a low priority to me. Doing it the way the are seems great, giving several years of runway, letting people know they need to contribute if they want to save it, etc. 
Agreed. This is a charity case, not something we should be spending tax dollars or Rams money on. There are far more important places to spend that money.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk


344
Full MemberFull Member

Post8:26 PM - Oct 19#34

To each their own, but our water towers are highly unique landmarks and, IMHO, all three should receive immediate and ongoing investment to make sure they don't collapse. 

It might be considered a charity case if the money were desired for beautification or high-end restoration -- but the ask here is to get it back in operable order for safe entry (and ultimately to prevent demolition).

1,165
Expert MemberExpert Member

Post8:31 PM - Oct 19#35

stldotage wrote:To each their own, but our water towers are highly unique landmarks and, IMHO, all three should receive immediate and ongoing investment to make sure they don't collapse. 

It might be considered a charity case if the money were desired for beautification or high-end restoration -- but the ask here is to get it back in operable order for safe entry (and ultimately to prevent demolition).
Then the city needs to find a way to make money off them. There's just no way to justify spending money on them when so much of our infrastructure is in the state it's in.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk


2,769
Life MemberLife Member

Post2:24 AM - Oct 20#36

It's a shame 44 cut through the north end of this park. It left unmolested it would certainly be one of our most beloved parks and probably have some a well funded support organization like Lafayette, Forest, and Tower Grove parks. The whole park is fairly rough when it comes to deferred maintenance. 

1,717
Totally AddictedTotally Addicted

Post3:19 PM - Oct 20#37

It’s not like this snuck up on us.  Was shut down for tours long ago.  Easily could’ve been an ARPA earmark.  

I’m actually shocked by the dismissive tone in trying to salvage something so unique and historic.  

344
Full MemberFull Member

Post3:33 PM - Oct 20#38

Same. ^

I understand the argument that this landmark could potentially drum up a good bit of private money without dipping as much into public funding, but still, it seems of outsized cultural, historical, and aesthetic importance to South City. And the Compton water tower can't generate money/revenue for the City without first being safe for the public to enter, of course.

Not that I am in the Elliott Davis business of one-sided, "You Paid For It"-style public investment scrutiny...but the city recently earmarked $5.5 million (mostly from ARPA) to stabilize four buildings on the North Side. While those buildings* are all legit landmarks for the North Side ...I have to say, if it's worth nearly $6 million to merely structurally stabilize crumbling cultural landmarks without much of a market value in the conventional sense, then certainly $8 million to restore the Compton Water Tower to working order is worth dipping into a public funding pool as well.

*(the Sara Lou building, Chuck Berry's house on Whittier, the Wellston streetcar loop building, and, the now unfortunately deemed too-far-gone and subsequently demolished Club Imperial)

1,165
Expert MemberExpert Member

Post4:15 PM - Oct 20#39

stldotage wrote:Same. ^

I understand the argument that this landmark could potentially drum up a good bit of private money without dipping as much into public funding, but still, it seems of outsized cultural, historical, and aesthetic importance to South City. And the Compton water tower can't generate money/revenue for the City without first being safe for the public to enter, of course.

Not that I am in the Elliott Davis business of one-sided, "You Paid For It"-style public investment scrutiny...but the city recently earmarked $5.5 million (mostly from ARPA) to stabilize four buildings on the North Side. While those buildings* are all legit landmarks for the North Side ...I have to say, if it's worth nearly $6 million to merely structurally stabilize crumbling cultural landmarks without much of a market value in the conventional sense, then certainly $8 million to restore the Compton Water Tower to working order is worth dipping into a public funding pool as well.

*(the Sara Lou building, Chuck Berry's house on Whittier, the Wellston streetcar loop building, and, the now unfortunately deemed too-far-gone and subsequently demolished Club Imperial)
Houses people may actually be able to live in are absolutely more valueable than a piece of infrastructure that's not even used by the city anymore.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk


344
Full MemberFull Member

Post4:23 PM - Oct 20#40

StlAlex wrote: ↑
4:15 PM - Oct 20
stldotage wrote:Same. ^

I understand the argument that this landmark could potentially drum up a good bit of private money without dipping as much into public funding, but still, it seems of outsized cultural, historical, and aesthetic importance to South City. And the Compton water tower can't generate money/revenue for the City without first being safe for the public to enter, of course.

Not that I am in the Elliott Davis business of one-sided, "You Paid For It"-style public investment scrutiny...but the city recently earmarked $5.5 million (mostly from ARPA) to stabilize four buildings on the North Side. While those buildings* are all legit landmarks for the North Side ...I have to say, if it's worth nearly $6 million to merely structurally stabilize crumbling cultural landmarks without much of a market value in the conventional sense, then certainly $8 million to restore the Compton Water Tower to working order is worth dipping into a public funding pool as well.

*(the Sara Lou building, Chuck Berry's house on Whittier, the Wellston streetcar loop building, and, the now unfortunately deemed too-far-gone and subsequently demolished Club Imperial)
Houses people may actually be able to live in are absolutely more valueable than a piece of infrastructure that's not even used by the city anymore.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk
Of the examples I mentioned, none was specifically proposed for housing. One is a streetcar barn after all.

1,165
Expert MemberExpert Member

Post4:50 PM - Oct 20#41

stldotage wrote:
StlAlex wrote: ↑
4:15 PM - Oct 20
stldotage wrote:Same. ^

I understand the argument that this landmark could potentially drum up a good bit of private money without dipping as much into public funding, but still, it seems of outsized cultural, historical, and aesthetic importance to South City. And the Compton water tower can't generate money/revenue for the City without first being safe for the public to enter, of course.

Not that I am in the Elliott Davis business of one-sided, "You Paid For It"-style public investment scrutiny...but the city recently earmarked $5.5 million (mostly from ARPA) to stabilize four buildings on the North Side. While those buildings* are all legit landmarks for the North Side ...I have to say, if it's worth nearly $6 million to merely structurally stabilize crumbling cultural landmarks without much of a market value in the conventional sense, then certainly $8 million to restore the Compton Water Tower to working order is worth dipping into a public funding pool as well.

*(the Sara Lou building, Chuck Berry's house on Whittier, the Wellston streetcar loop building, and, the now unfortunately deemed too-far-gone and subsequently demolished Club Imperial)
Houses people may actually be able to live in are absolutely more valueable than a piece of infrastructure that's not even used by the city anymore.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk
Of the examples I mentioned, none was specifically proposed for housing. One is a streetcar barn after all.
Of the examples you mentioned, all could and hopefully will be purchased and redeveloped for residential or commercial use should they be saved for $5.5M. The water tower will never be sold and redeveloped, no one will live in it, it won't be a tax contributing business. It will always be a fairly niche landmark that people will look at and say "that's pretty neat."

It would be different if the city had tons of excess money and infrastructure that wasn't crumbling or if the cost for renovations was exceedingly cheap, but it's not. I hope they can find donations for it, I would hate to see it collapse, but it's just not a good expenditure of our limited money for what return it would offer.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk


623
Senior MemberSenior Member

Post5:33 PM - Oct 20#42

stldotage wrote: ↑
3:33 PM - Oct 20
Same. ^

I understand the argument that this landmark could potentially drum up a good bit of private money without dipping as much into public funding, but still, it seems of outsized cultural, historical, and aesthetic importance to South City. And the Compton water tower can't generate money/revenue for the City without first being safe for the public to enter, of course.

Not that I am in the Elliott Davis business of one-sided, "You Paid For It"-style public investment scrutiny...but the city recently earmarked $5.5 million (mostly from ARPA) to stabilize four buildings on the North Side. While those buildings* are all legit landmarks for the North Side ...I have to say, if it's worth nearly $6 million to merely structurally stabilize crumbling cultural landmarks without much of a market value in the conventional sense, then certainly $8 million to restore the Compton Water Tower to working order is worth dipping into a public funding pool as well.

*(the Sara Lou building, Chuck Berry's house on Whittier, the Wellston streetcar loop building, and, the now unfortunately deemed too-far-gone and subsequently demolished Club Imperial)
I'm all for promoting/saving things that are comparative advantages of STL.  I get the ROI calculation but we can't *solely* live life that way. The water tower provides historic city vibes and STL needs all the good vibes it can get. Booming southern/sunbelt don't have such cool old water towers so I think it's worth it to spend tax $.  We can out-vibe them here, so count me in!

497
Full MemberFull Member

Post7:05 PM - Oct 20#43

Well then I hope some of you are considering coming out to that meeting tonight then, as opposed to loosely discussing in an online forum. 

344
Full MemberFull Member

Post7:31 PM - Oct 20#44

SRQ2STL wrote: ↑
7:05 PM - Oct 20
Well then I hope some of you are considering coming out to that meeting tonight then, as opposed to loosely discussing in an online forum. 
I can't go to the meeting but I'd donate!

502
Senior MemberSenior Member

Post9:03 PM - Oct 20#45

Link to donate and the organization: https://watertowerfoundation.org/

I hope we can save the tower and then this leads to more money for the park overall and improve it!

13K
Life MemberLife Member

Post10:28 PM - Oct 20#46

The donate link to Paypal isn't working 

3,865
Life MemberLife Member

Post1:35 PM - Oct 21#47

This is a landmark worth saving & a private-public partnership should be considered. If the City owns the park, the City should pitch in. This is a historic landmark & if we let them fall down, we lose what makes our City unique. While I get the "we have greater needs" comments, the fact that anyone would be ok with the tower going in the disrepair or eventually being gone is beyond me. We have lost way too many landmarks. If you've been in the tower, you know how unique & amazing it is. We need more Compton Hill Water Towers in STL, not strip malls, fast food & trash developments. This landmark should be saved, renovated at any cost & reopened to the public so the next generations can appreciate it. 

623
Senior MemberSenior Member

Post3:12 PM - Oct 21#48

DogtownBnR wrote: ↑
1:35 PM - Oct 21
This is a landmark worth saving & a private-public partnership should be considered. If the City owns the park, the City should pitch in. This is a historic landmark & if we let them fall down, we lose what makes our City unique. While I get the "we have greater needs" comments, the fact that anyone would be ok with the tower going in the disrepair or eventually being gone is beyond me. We have lost way too many landmarks. If you've been in the tower, you know how unique & amazing it is. We need more Compton Hill Water Towers in STL, not strip malls, fast food & trash developments. This landmark should be saved, renovated at any cost & reopened to the public so the next generations can appreciate it. 
100%

1,212
Expert MemberExpert Member

Post3:37 PM - Oct 21#49

PeterXCV wrote: ↑
4:16 PM - Oct 18
Methinks the Compton Heights bourgeoisie could cough up the money to restore the water tower.
Reiterating my financing idea...

1,365
Veteran MemberVeteran Member

Post5:46 AM - Oct 22#50

GoHarvOrGoHome wrote: ↑
2:24 AM - Oct 20
It's a shame 44 cut through the north end of this park. It left unmolested it would certainly be one of our most beloved parks and probably have some a well funded support organization like Lafayette, Forest, and Tower Grove parks. The whole park is fairly rough when it comes to deferred maintenance. 
Would be sweet to figure out a way to lower and cap 44 there to extend the park.

Read more posts (0 remaining)