Tapatalk

Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh

3,762
Life MemberLife Member
3,762

PostMay 25, 2017#1

Starting a general thread for Pittsburgh topics.

First up, despite the hype Pittsburgh and Allegheny Co. still losing population:

http://www.post-gazette.com/local/city/ ... 1705250024

1,064
Expert MemberExpert Member
1,064

PostMay 25, 2017#2

Is Pittsburgh PA maybe a similar story to STL, where it is simultaneously shedding lower income residents in struggling, high vacancy neighborhoods in exchange for higher income residents in dense, high-amenity neighborhoods?

3,762
Life MemberLife Member
3,762

PostMay 25, 2017#3

onecity wrote:
May 25, 2017
Is Pittsburgh PA maybe a similar story to STL, where it is simultaneously shedding lower income residents in struggling, high vacancy neighborhoods in exchange for higher income residents in dense, high-amenity neighborhoods?
That would be my guess. For whatever reason, though, metro Pittsburgh has steadily lost population while metro STL has steadily gained population overall. I think.

6,140
Life MemberLife Member
6,140

PostMay 26, 2017#4

Geography might play a role there. Available land for affordable exurban construction might be more scarce, thus driving prices up and limiting the potential for sprawl. Metro St. Louis has bee gaining population slightly, on paper, but the definition of what's in the metro area keeps getting bigger too. That may not be possible there.

1,213
Expert MemberExpert Member
1,213

PostOct 24, 2017#5

Geography seems to be a counterweight to Pittsburgh's expansion, but the irregular topography adds to its urbanity - my impression is that Pittsburgh's downtown is abnormally dense for a city of its size (even its historical size) precisely because it is hard to build there.

Another interesting point of comparison is fragmented local government: definitely not at the same magnitude as St Louis, but Pittsburgh also features municipality enclaves like Cincinnati (independent municipalities that are completely surrounded by the larger city). Again, this makes sense given the topography.

2,430
Life MemberLife Member
2,430

PostOct 25, 2017#6

Pittsburgh fares quite well on a lot of economic indicators compared to other compact city peers.

For example, it has the lowest 2016 poverty rate with 19.2%, and only Baltimore and Pittsburgh have a black poverty rate under 30%. Saint Louis City fares pretty well, too on poverty, tho it has a higher disparity between rates of black (32%%) and whites (13.2%). Minneapolis has a whopping disparity among the compact city group with the lowest white poverty rate (12.4%) and highest black poverty rate (43.7%).

(I looked at STL and compact peers Baltimore, Pittsburgh, Milwaukee, Buffalo, Cincinnati, Cleveland, and Minneapolis; all of which are under 100 sq. mi. Compact non-peers include SanFran, D.C., & SEA,)

13K
Life MemberLife Member
13K

PostJul 23, 2020#7

Pittsburgh Post-Gazette- Hitting the mark: Target to open a store in Downtown Pittsburgh

https://www.post-gazette.com/business/d ... 2007230119

12K
Life MemberLife Member
12K

PostAug 15, 2023#8

Pittsburgh and the University of Pittsburgh have ambitious plans to transform former steel mill sites into a center of biotech manufacturing. 



https://www.pittmed.pitt.edu/sites/defa ... 2023_0.pdf

13K
Life MemberLife Member
13K

PostOct 25, 2024#9

WPXI - $600M to go toward revitalizing Downtown Pittsburgh as part of 10-year plan
A new, historic plan aims to revitalize Downtown Pittsburgh.

Governor Josh Shapiro’s administration announced Friday that elected officials, corporate leaders, private developers, organized labor, nonprofits and artists from Pittsburgh came together for this collective effort to improve Downtown.

Projects are already in the works that have equaled about $600 million, all of which are part of the initial phase of the plan and are expected to wrap in 2028.
https://www.wpxi.com/news/local/governo ... I5VMS6PE4/

2,260
Life MemberLife Member
2,260

PostOct 26, 2024#10

This is misleading. Pennsylvania just announced $62 million towards the downtown Pittsburgh revitalization, on top of $22 million from the city's redevelopment agency and $40 million already committed by private institutions. They don't seem to have funding sources or commitments for the remaining few hundred million.

However, we could only dream of real investments from the state or major investments from our businesses sector.

PostJan 05, 2025#11

https://www.post-gazette.com/business/d ... 2501030079

US Steel may move out of downtown Pittsburgh after Biden blocked Nippon Steel deal.

They currently occupy 230,000 SF of US Steel Tower and are the 2nd largest tenant after UPMC.

PostJul 01, 2025#12

https://www.railway.supply/en/pittsburg ... %20to%20$3.

PRT approves major cuts to transit, totaling a ~35% cut.

The cuts and fare hike is to fill a $119 million budget deficit.

Fares will by hiked by $0.25, service will end at 11 PM, the Silver Line LRT will be discontinued, 12 light rail stations will be closed, 41 bus lines will be ended, and special services for large events will also be ended. PRT will also lay off nearly 40% of their workforce.

The agency says that they could reverse the budget cuts if the state approves a pending transit funding bill, however Republicans in the state senate are currently holding it up.

13K
Life MemberLife Member
13K

PostJul 02, 2025#13

Sounds like a gift to the oil industry.

965
Super MemberSuper Member
965

Post7:02 PM - 17 days ago#14

‘Affordable’ Pittsburgh doesn’t have enough affordable housing – here’s why
https://theconversation.com/affordable-pittsburgh-doesnt-have-enough-affordable-housing-heres-why-280113

2,838
Life MemberLife Member
2,838

Post5:18 AM - 16 days ago#15

The 54 story BNY tower is now almost empty.  This Pittsburgh Newspaper writer says it should be demolished to restore downtown Pittsburgh.

https://www.post-gazette.com/opinion/br ... 2602150085

More info on the tower...
The Move-Out: BNY (formerly BNY Mellon) is vacating its 1.6 million square foot space in the 54-story tower and relocating employees to a new campus on Ross Street.

Vacancy Timeline: While significant portions are already being vacated, the main lease on the building does not expire until 2028.Current Status:
As of early 2026, nearly half of the workforce has already moved out, and other tenants in the building are also relocating, causing some areas to be empty or gutted.

Future Outlook: The building, owned by MetLife, faces an uncertain future due to high vacancy rates, with some industry experts discussing it could become a "zombie" building or even face demolition.
Screenshot_20260508_001750_Chrome.jpg (315.59KiB)

521
Senior MemberSenior Member
521

Post5:30 AM - 16 days ago#16

I was reliably informed that only St. Louis’s downtown has a vacancy problem and therefore the worst city in the United States.

As for demolition of that building, lol. It’s probably easier to redevelop than the AT&T Building in STL. Floor plates look a little bit smaller and it’s right on a transit line. Like AT&T, the smart approach would be to phase the redevelopment. Start by saving some office space, but introduce residential, hotel, and lab space. If office doesn’t do well, slowly convert to residential abs more lab space. It might take a decade, but the long term benefits outweigh the demo and be done option.

Granted I don’t know the state of Pittsburgh in general other than their baseball team being dragged on twitter as being trash.

611
Senior MemberSenior Member
611

Post5:44 AM - 16 days ago#17

Chris Stritzel wrote:I was reliably informed that only St. Louis’s downtown has a vacancy problem and therefore the worst city in the United States.

As for demolition of that building, lol. It’s probably easier to redevelop than the AT&T Building in STL. Floor plates look a little bit smaller and it’s right on a transit line. Like AT&T, the smart approach would be to phase the redevelopment. Start by saving some office space, but introduce residential, hotel, and lab space. If office doesn’t do well, slowly convert to residential abs more lab space. It might take a decade, but the long term benefits outweigh the demo and be done option.

Granted I don’t know the state of Pittsburgh in general other than their baseball team being dragged on twitter as being trash.
Downtown Pittsburgh is in a far better shape than downtown STL. It's a safe assumption they'll have an easier time redeveloping it than we've had with AT&T.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk


521
Senior MemberSenior Member
521

Post7:23 AM - 16 days ago#18

StlAlex wrote:
5:44 AM - 16 days ago
Chris Stritzel wrote:I was reliably informed that only St. Louis’s downtown has a vacancy problem and therefore the worst city in the United States.

As for demolition of that building, lol. It’s probably easier to redevelop than the AT&T Building in STL. Floor plates look a little bit smaller and it’s right on a transit line. Like AT&T, the smart approach would be to phase the redevelopment. Start by saving some office space, but introduce residential, hotel, and lab space. If office doesn’t do well, slowly convert to residential abs more lab space. It might take a decade, but the long term benefits outweigh the demo and be done option.

Granted I don’t know the state of Pittsburgh in general other than their baseball team being dragged on twitter as being trash.
Downtown Pittsburgh is in a far better shape than downtown STL. It's a safe assumption they'll have an easier time redeveloping it than we've had with AT&T.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk
Then the news opinion about demoing that building in Pittsburgh is really stupid. Hopefully people over there see it as such.

611
Senior MemberSenior Member
611

Post8:13 AM - 16 days ago#19

Chris Stritzel wrote:
StlAlex wrote:
5:44 AM - 16 days ago
Chris Stritzel wrote:I was reliably informed that only St. Louis’s downtown has a vacancy problem and therefore the worst city in the United States.

As for demolition of that building, lol. It’s probably easier to redevelop than the AT&T Building in STL. Floor plates look a little bit smaller and it’s right on a transit line. Like AT&T, the smart approach would be to phase the redevelopment. Start by saving some office space, but introduce residential, hotel, and lab space. If office doesn’t do well, slowly convert to residential abs more lab space. It might take a decade, but the long term benefits outweigh the demo and be done option.

Granted I don’t know the state of Pittsburgh in general other than their baseball team being dragged on twitter as being trash.
Downtown Pittsburgh is in a far better shape than downtown STL. It's a safe assumption they'll have an easier time redeveloping it than we've had with AT&T.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk
Then the news opinion about demoing that building in Pittsburgh is really stupid. Hopefully people over there see it as such.
I mean it's one of ten "thoughts" from the opinion editor on a failing newspaper. One of his other thoughts was that downtown Pittsburgh is basically dead and not coming back, even though it currently supports a Target, Burlington, and Brooks Brothers. If DT PIT is dead, then DT STL truly has no hope at all and we may as well give up. It's not like an actual view of anyone who's opinion matters.

He's right that it'll be difficult to fill, but I expect PA and the local business community to be a bigger help than we have here. It's not in Pittsburgh's character to tear down a 725 ft tower.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk


2,838
Life MemberLife Member
2,838

Post3:43 AM - 15 days ago#20

StlAlex wrote:
5:44 AM - 16 days ago
Chris Stritzel wrote:I was reliably informed that only St. Louis’s downtown has a vacancy problem and therefore the worst city in the United States.

As for demolition of that building, lol. It’s probably easier to redevelop than the AT&T Building in STL. Floor plates look a little bit smaller and it’s right on a transit line. Like AT&T, the smart approach would be to phase the redevelopment. Start by saving some office space, but introduce residential, hotel, and lab space. If office doesn’t do well, slowly convert to residential abs more lab space. It might take a decade, but the long term benefits outweigh the demo and be done option.

Granted I don’t know the state of Pittsburgh in general other than their baseball team being dragged on twitter as being trash.
Downtown Pittsburgh is in a far better shape than downtown STL. It's a safe assumption they'll have an easier time redeveloping it than we've had with AT&T.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk
Actually its not "far" better.  The crime and homeless "perceptions" and reality are similar. Vacancy rates are going up... especially after this tower empties out.  
Their downtown has no full frocery store and the plansto open a new grocery store this year (news of it last year) just announced this past week it is not opening now. 😢 It would have been the first full grocery downtown.

Downtown Pittsburgh is undergoing a difficult, multi-year transition driven by high office vacancies (2025 approx. 18.8% and rising), reduced foot traffic, and the shift to hybrid work. While public-private partnerships aim to convert empty offices into residential units and enhance public spaces, local businesses face immediate challenges from construction, crime concerns, and fewer downtown workers.Key Challenges & Current Status (May 2026)Dñ Declining Workforce & Vacancy: Downtown office workers have decreased by 17% over two decades. Commercial office vacancies reached 18.8% in 2025, up from ~10% in 2020, as companies right-size, leaving behind empty spaces.

Business Disruptions: Despite hosting the 2026 NFL Draft, many downtown restaurants reported poor business, describing the area as a "ghost town" compared to pre-pandemic times. Ongoing renovations and construction for, and since, the Draft caused major dips in sales for businesses in spots like Market Square.Safety and Maintenance: Concerns remain regarding increased homelessness, substance abuse, and damaged infrastructure, with residents and business owners describing the area as run-down.Lack of Amenities: Critics note a lack of everyday services like grocery stores and urgent care centers, making it less appealing for residential living
Retail and Rental Costs: High rental rates and limited parking have caused local businesses to struggle.

611
Senior MemberSenior Member
611

Post4:18 AM - 15 days ago#21

matguy70 wrote:
StlAlex wrote:
5:44 AM - 16 days ago
Chris Stritzel wrote:I was reliably informed that only St. Louis’s downtown has a vacancy problem and therefore the worst city in the United States.

As for demolition of that building, lol. It’s probably easier to redevelop than the AT&T Building in STL. Floor plates look a little bit smaller and it’s right on a transit line. Like AT&T, the smart approach would be to phase the redevelopment. Start by saving some office space, but introduce residential, hotel, and lab space. If office doesn’t do well, slowly convert to residential abs more lab space. It might take a decade, but the long term benefits outweigh the demo and be done option.

Granted I don’t know the state of Pittsburgh in general other than their baseball team being dragged on twitter as being trash.
Downtown Pittsburgh is in a far better shape than downtown STL. It's a safe assumption they'll have an easier time redeveloping it than we've had with AT&T.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk
Actually its not "far" better.  The crime and homeless "perceptions" and reality are similar. Vacancy rates are going up... especially after this tower empties out.  
Their downtown has no full frocery store and the plansto open a new grocery store this year (news of it last year) just announced this past week it is not opening now. 😢 It would have been the first full grocery downtown.

Downtown Pittsburgh is undergoing a difficult, multi-year transition driven by high office vacancies (2025 approx. 18.8% and rising), reduced foot traffic, and the shift to hybrid work. While public-private partnerships aim to convert empty offices into residential units and enhance public spaces, local businesses face immediate challenges from construction, crime concerns, and fewer downtown workers.Key Challenges & Current Status (May 2026)Dñ Declining Workforce & Vacancy: Downtown office workers have decreased by 17% over two decades. Commercial office vacancies reached 18.8% in 2025, up from ~10% in 2020, as companies right-size, leaving behind empty spaces.

Business Disruptions: Despite hosting the 2026 NFL Draft, many downtown restaurants reported poor business, describing the area as a "ghost town" compared to pre-pandemic times. Ongoing renovations and construction for, and since, the Draft caused major dips in sales for businesses in spots like Market Square.Safety and Maintenance: Concerns remain regarding increased homelessness, substance abuse, and damaged infrastructure, with residents and business owners describing the area as run-down.Lack of Amenities: Critics note a lack of everyday services like grocery stores and urgent care centers, making it less appealing for residential living
Retail and Rental Costs: High rental rates and limited parking have caused local businesses to struggle.
Well there's what AI says and what reality says. It would take downtown STL to get some 1.3 million square feet of new leases to catch up to where downtown Pittsburgh is at 19-20% vacant. Downtown STL is more than 30% vacant right now.

Pittsburgh will have 1 vacant large building come 2028, STL has several right now for more than a decade and adding more.

Pittsburgh also has multiple DGX style stores and the Target has a significant grocery section, which probably handles the grocery demands.

It is decades ahead of STL right now.

Sent from my SM-S936U using Tapatalk