Tapatalk

Earth City: an anti-Urban Living history

Earth City: an anti-Urban Living history

2,190
Life MemberLife Member
2,190

PostMay 21, 2013#1

DeBaliviere asked about the origin of "Earth City" in the Macy's thread. Here's a start (P-D, by Virginia Hick, copyright 1981, excerpted). As I recall, the place endured numerous bankruptcies; I'll add more clips as I find them.
The 1,300-acre development, begun in 1970 by the Linclay Corp., was to have been a city within a city, with a daytime population of 35,000 and 12,000 permanent residents. Ford Motor Credit's <current> proposal would eliminate all residentially zoned property from the development.

The facts speak for themselves, said J. William Newbold, attorney for Ford Motor Credit. The land was zoned for apartments for 10 years and not one person came forward to develop it. You have to assume it's not economically feasible as apartments.

The original project envisioned by J. Dale Perkinson, president of Linclay, was to have had sites for industrial and office buildings, stores, apartments, lakes, bike trails, a swimming pool, a golf course and riding stables. But Linclay encountered financial difficulties and sold out in 1974 to a partnership headed by developer Trammell Crow of Dallas.

In 1977, only 160 acres of the project had been developed. Ford Motor Credit, a subsidiary of Ford Motor Co. Inc. and the main lender for the project, foreclosed and took full ownership of the undeveloped land. Rather than developing the land itself, the company has concentrated on selling the parcels to others who would build on it.

Since it took over, Ford has sold most of the 785 acres of property zoned for industrial or commercial use that was suitable for development. We're down to odd-lot parcels, Newbold said. They're too small or too large for a variety of uses.

Now the company is turning to the 278 acres just west of the Bridgeton city limits, between Interstate 70 and St. Charles Rock Road that is zoned for multifamily residential use.

A report to the county government in 1978 stressed the need for industrial sites, Newbold said. It is the industrially zoned property that creates lasting jobs, and there's a shortage of that kind of property in St. Louis County, he said.

When the County Council rejected a proposal last summer to zone the Missouri Bottoms for industrial use, several councilmen said they were eager to find other industrial sites.

In the new plan, the southernmost 50 acres would be rezoned for planned commercial use. The shopping center would contain two strips of retail shops, two fast-food restaurants, a sitdown restaurant, a theater, a bank, a motel and an auto service center.

The 229 acres proposed for industrial use would contain offices, office/warehouses and factories. The office buildings would be built around one of the proposed lakes and along the western boundary of the project, near the northbound leg of the Earth City Expressway. Eight office/warehouses are planned in the center of the industrial portion, and seven factories would be built along the eastern edge and the Bridgeton city limits.

A recreation center is planned for the northern corner near St. Charles Rock Road. It would include indoor and outdoor tennis courts, racquetball courts and more offices.

PostMay 21, 2013#2

P-D copyright 1984, excerpted
When Walmart Stores Inc. began building in Earth City this spring, the wheat had to be harvested early on the company's 10-acre lot. The farmer was left with straw, but Ford Motor Credit Co. was happy.

Each acre Ford sells in its 1,175- acre office and industrial park puts it another step closer to getting out of a $35 million hole. To cut maintenance costs, Ford has contracted with a farmer to grow corn and wheat on the vacant lots.

And there is still plenty of vacant land, although sales have picked up in the last year. Since Earth City was launched in 1970 with much fanfare and grand plans, 318 of its 950 developable acres have been sold. 128 of those acres were sold in the last five years.

John Basilico, Ford's local manager, says it will be another four or five years before the giant credit company recoups its investment. But Basilico is a patient man. In a recent interview, he said it would be take 10 to 12 years more to fully develop the park.

United Parcel Service owns the largest single chunk of Earth City with 34 acres. The Prudential Life Insurance Company of America is probably the largest single building owner with four warehouses and an office building, all leased to others.

Companies that have leased space include McDonnell Douglas Corp., ACF Industries, Schnuck Markets, Boise Cascade Corp., Raychem Corp. and Anheuser Busch. In all, the park has 2.7 million square feet in buildings.

So far this year, Ford has sold 16 acres, including the 10-acre Walmart site, and has another 16 acres under contract and ready for closing. More than 160 businesses operate in the park with about 4,000 employees.

Ford never intended to be the developer of Earth City. It started out as the lender. But the company ended up with the project in 1977 after two developers failed to make a go of it.

Earth City was the brainchild of Linclay Corp., headed by J. Dale Perkinson. Original plans called for a mini-city to rise out of what had been prime farmland abutting the Missouri River in north St. Louis County. There would be jobs, stores, housing, lakes, bike trails, swimming pool, golf course and riding stables.

In 1974 Linclay backed out of Earth City, victim of a variety of problems. Suits brought by environmentalists slowed land development, the recession was starting up and development at Westport was attracting potential customers. The next developer was Crow-St. Louis Industrial Inc., a partnership headed by developer Trammell Crow of Dallas. Crow -- hit hard by the recession -- lasted three years. Ford took over the project in a friendly foreclosure suit in June 1977. Both Linclay and Crow still own land and buildings in the park.

Today, Earth City is strictly offices and warehouses with one hotel, the Harley, which stands near the entrance from Interstate 70. The park is bounded on the south by Interstate 70, on the north by St. Charles Rock Road, on the east by Bridgeton and on the west by the Missouri River.

The 293 acres that were zoned for multi-family housing were re-zoned in 1981 for commercial and industrial use. Those acres lie east of the Earth City Expressway and are now planted with corn.

Yet for years, developers have shied away from Earth City, afraid that their investments would not appreciate the way they have in Westport and along Highway 40 and Interstate 270. The lack of restaurants and retail shops also has hurt the location, although the proposed $500 million Riverport development should solve that problem.

'It's in the right location yet it isn't, ' says Ronald H. Silverman, executive vice president of Turco Development Co. 'Earth City will move into its own as the Westport area becomes saturated.'

Silverman said Earth City had been hurt by the early suits, the foreclosures and the accompanying publicity. 'The problem, a lot of it, is perception. Some people think, 'I don't want to get involved out there, it's a problem.' They really do get a bad rap.'

Vernon Martens, who specializes in industrial sales for Coldwell Banker, says that Earth City was way ahead of its time when planned by Linclay -- an assessment shared by Basilico.

'I think Earth City is just coming into its own now, ' says Martens. 'It was conceived at the same time Westport was taking off, and at that time Westport was more attractive. It was closer in, land was available and easy to develop, and there were restaurants and shops at Westport Plaza.'

So after 14 years, Earth City may just be on the verge of coming into its own. And as Basilico notes, there is only so much land left along 40 and 270. Eventually the choices will narrow.

2,093
Life MemberLife Member
2,093

PostMay 21, 2013#3

Interesting. Thanks for sharing Bonwich. As a schoolkid in St. Chuck I remember passing by Earth City on I-70 en route to field trips to Powell Hall, the Art Museum, etc. At 9 yrs. old I recall thinking it sounded like a really cool place to live.

Of course this was 1981 and my infatuation with the soulless office park was probably only name deep. Earth City sounded a lot like Cloud City and maybe I thought Lando Calrissian lived there or something.

5,433
Super ModeratorSuper Moderator
5,433

PostMay 22, 2013#4

Bonwich, thanks for the history lesson on Earth City. I always love it when you dig into the P-D archives and share it with us here.

(BTW, if you feel like offering some perspective via the P-D archives in the Famous-Barr/Macy's Downtown thread, please feel free to do so if you dig in the archives and find something to share. I really hope downtown retail can rebound after Macy's closes, but I'm just not as optimistic as others here, and I'm not quite as optimistic as I used to be. Don't get me wrong as others have- I am still bullish on downtown St. Louis long-term. I just think its continued recovery is going to be without significant retail for awhile longer.)

Anyway, like DeBaliviere, I always wondered how Earth City came to be. I always thought the name sounded so absurd. Then, when I first moved to St. Louis after college in the late 1990s, I had the privilege of working there. This was also around the time that Office Space was in theaters. And all I can say about my work experience is that I would have rather worked at Initech. My job was not great, and it wasn't awful either, but it probably felt at least 10x worse than it was because I had to go to Earth City five days a week. I can't begin to list all of the reasons why, but I really struggle to think of a work environment that's more mind-numbing or soul-crushing than Earth City. Or maybe that's just the city lover in me talking.

4,489
Super ModeratorSuper Moderator
4,489

PostMay 22, 2013#5

Great information and history.

Thanks for sharing.